I’m a DJ and I Hate Your Song Requests

  • By: Amanda Coscarelli

This story has been submitted by a LOOP reader…

There’s a moment every night when I realize the night is no longer mine.

Up until then, I’m in control. I’m building something. A slow burn. Maybe I start with house—something warm, rhythmic, easy to melt into. The bar is filling up, people are loosening, conversations are still happening. I can guide the room. That’s the whole point of DJing, whether people realize it or not: it’s not about playing songs, it’s about controlling energy.

And then you show up. You don’t come alone, either. You never do. You come in waves—groups of girls clutching phones, guys already sweating through their shirts, someone celebrating a birthday, someone who “used to DJ a little in college.” And suddenly, the booth isn’t a booth anymore—it’s a suggestion box.

“Can you play something we can dance to?”

That’s always my favorite one. I’m watching a packed floor—people moving, drinks in the air, heads nodding—and someone leans in like they’ve just discovered fire. “Something we can dance to.” I always wonder what they think I’ve been doing for the last hour. Soundtracking a funeral? But I smile. Or at least I pretend to. Because part of this job is performance, and not just musically. You nod, you pretend to hear them over the monitors, you cup your ear like maybe the problem is volume and not the fact that they just asked you to derail an entire set for a song that peaked in 2012.

Suddenly, the booth isn’t a booth anymore—it’s a suggestion box.

Then comes the phone. It’s always the phone. They don’t even say anything at first—they just shove it in your face, Spotify open, brightness at full blast, like they’re presenting evidence in court. And it’s never subtle. It’s always a moment. A track they need. A song that will “literally make everyone go crazy.”

 

It won’t. That’s the part they don’t understand. What works in your car, what works at a house party, what works screaming lyrics with your friends—that doesn’t always work in a club. A dance floor is fragile. It’s a living thing. You don’t just throw a random song at it and expect it to survive. But explaining that? Impossible. So you nod again. You give them the DJ equivalent of “I’ll think about it.” Maybe you even type something into your laptop to make it look convincing. And they walk away, satisfied, already telling their friends, “He’s gonna play it.” I’m not going to play it.

 

And then, five minutes later, they’re back. 

 

“Did you play it yet?”

 

No. Because I’m in the middle of something. Because the BPM doesn’t match. Because the key is wrong. Because the entire room is finally locked in and I’m not about to kill it for your throwback request that belongs at a wedding, not a nightclub. But again—smile. Nod. “I got you.”

 

Related | A Bouncer Threw Me Out While I Was Unconscious… I Woke Up In the ER

Here’s the truth no one wants to hear: the best nights happen when no one talks to me.

When the crowd trusts me enough to just… go with it. When I can take them somewhere unexpected—dip into something darker, build it back up, drop something they didn’t know they needed. That’s when it feels like art. Like connection. Like I’m not just a human jukebox.

But those nights are rare.

Most nights, I’m negotiating.

“Play some hip-hop!”

“Play more EDM!”

“Play something old school!”

“Play something new!”

“Play my song!”

Everyone wants something different, and somehow, it’s my job to make them all feel like they’re getting what they want—even when they’re not.

And then there are the aggressive ones. The ones who don’t ask—they demand. They lean too far into the booth, slurring, “Bro, you HAVE to play this.” Like we’re friends. Like we planned this together. Like I haven’t spent years learning how to read a room, structure a set, mix properly—just to be overridden by someone three vodka sodas deep.

Everyone wants something different, and somehow, it’s my job to make them all feel like they’re getting what they want—even when they’re not.

I’ve had people get mad. Actually mad. Like I personally ruined their night because I didn’t play their request. One guy once stood there for ten straight minutes, arms crossed, just staring at me, waiting. As if sheer willpower was going to make me cave and drop his song in the middle of a peak-time set. I didn’t.

He flipped me off and left the booth like I’d betrayed him. And yet—here’s the part I don’t like admitting—sometimes, rarely, a request works. Someone asks for something unexpected but perfect. Something that fits the moment better than what I had lined up. And when I drop it, the room reacts—really reacts. That electric surge where everything clicks and you feel it in your chest.

Those moments mess with me. Because they give people just enough hope to keep asking.

But they don’t see the hundred other requests that would’ve cleared the floor.

So yeah—I hate your song requests. Not because I hate you. Not because I think I’m above it. But because when I’m up there, I’m trying to build something bigger than any one song. And every request is a reminder that most people don’t come to experience the night—they come to hear their moment. And those are two very different things.

So next time you’re at a club, and the DJ is locked in, the floor is moving, and the vibe feels just right? Don’t tap him on the shoulder. Don’t pull out your phone. Just dance. Trust me—I’ve got you.

Read More