I Did Karaoke in Front of My Favorite Pop Star. I Was Singing Her Song.

  • By: Amanda Coscarelli

This story has been submitted by a LOOP reader…

There are a lot of ways to embarrass yourself in public. Tripping on a curb. Waving back at someone who wasn’t waving at you. Accidentally liking a post from 2016. But I can confidently say I’ve unlocked a very specific, deeply personal nightmare: singing your favorite pop star’s song at karaoke… while she is standing ten feet away watching you.

It started like most bad decisions do—after two drinks and a group chat message that said, “Let’s go out tonight.” We ended up at this dimly lit karaoke bar tucked behind a taco spot, the kind of place where the mic cuts out every few songs and the crowd ranges from overly confident to aggressively off-key. Perfect. I wasn’t planning on singing. I never do. I’m the friend who claps, hypes everyone up, and records blurry videos for Instagram. But my friend Jess put my name down anyway. “You’re doing it,” she said, already scrolling through the song list. “And you’re singing that song.”

That song. The one I’d had on repeat for months. The one I sang in my car like I was headlining a stadium tour. The one by my absolute favorite pop star—the woman whose voice I had tried (and failed) to imitate more times than I could count. I protested for a solid five minutes, but by then it was already too late. My name was on the screen. There was no backing out without looking like a coward.

“Fine,” I said, grabbing the mic when they called me up. “But you’re all singing with me.”

The intro started. I took a breath. And honestly? For the first thirty seconds, I kind of killed it. The crowd was into it, my friends were screaming, and I was just drunk enough to believe I sounded amazing. Then the energy in the room shifted. It wasn’t obvious at first—just a ripple, like when people suddenly start paying attention to something behind you. I thought maybe someone famous-adjacent had walked in, or a birthday group had arrived. I didn’t turn around. Rookie mistake.

The energy in the room shifted. It wasn’t obvious at first—just a ripple, like when people suddenly start paying attention to something behind you.

I hit the chorus—loud, dramatic, fully committed—and that’s when Jess’s face changed. Not in a “you’re doing great!” way. More like a “something is deeply, cosmically wrong” way. I followed her line of sight. And there she was.

 

My favorite pop star. The actual, real-life human being whose song I was currently butchering into a karaoke mic. Standing near the bar. Watching me. Watching. Me.

 

There are moments in life where your brain just…short-circuits. This was one of them. I forgot the lyrics instantly, which is impressive considering I had practically memorized them. My voice cracked in a way that can only be described as spiritually humiliating. And instead of gracefully stopping, I did what any panicking person would do: I kept going. I sang harder. Louder. Wronger.

 

At one point, I even pointed at her during a line like I was dedicating the performance. I don’t know why I did that. I truly don’t. It felt like my body had been hijacked by chaos. My friends were losing their minds. Half cheering, half dying. The rest of the bar had caught on too, phones subtly (and not-so-subtly) pointed in our direction. And her? She was smiling. Not laughing—thank God—but smiling in this slightly amused, slightly impressed way, like she couldn’t believe what she was witnessing but was enjoying it anyway.

 

Related | A Bouncer Threw Me Out While I Was Unconscious… I Woke Up In the ER

I made it to the end of the song. Barely. I hit the final note—again, incorrectly—and the room erupted. Applause, cheers, a couple of sympathetic whistles. I handed the mic back like it was evidence in a crime and immediately tried to disappear into the crowd.

Jess grabbed my arm. “You have to go say hi.”

“Absolutely not,” I said, already sweating through my outfit. But peer pressure is a powerful force, and before I knew it, I was being gently shoved toward the bar. Up close, she looked exactly like herself. Effortless. Glowing. Completely out of place in a sticky-floored karaoke bar—and yet somehow totally comfortable in it.

I opened my mouth to apologize, but she beat me to it. “That was bold,” she said, smiling. Bold. Not good. Not amazing. Bold.

“I’m so sorry,” I blurted out. “Of all the songs—I didn’t know you were here—I swear I’m not usually—”

She laughed, cutting me off. “No, I loved it. It takes guts to sing that song. It’s not easy.”

I stared at her, trying to process the fact that my favorite artist had just validated my chaotic performance. “Did I…completely ruin it?” I asked.

She tilted her head, pretending to consider it. “Let’s just say you made it your own.” Which, honestly, is the nicest possible way to say yes.

We talked for maybe two minutes. She was kind, funny, and way more normal than I expected. Then she got pulled away by whoever she was there with, and just like that, it was over.

There are moments in life where your brain just…short-circuits. This was one of them.

I went back to my friends, who immediately exploded into questions, screams, and exaggerated reenactments of my performance.

“YOU POINTED AT HER,” Jess kept yelling.

“I KNOW,” I said, covering my face. “I don’t know why I did that.”

We stayed out for another hour, but nothing could top that moment. By the time I got home, my voice was gone, my dignity was hanging by a thread, and my phone was full of videos I will absolutely never post.

But here’s the thing—I don’t regret it. Because for one surreal, slightly humiliating, completely unforgettable night, I got to sing my heart out to my favorite song… and the person who made it got to hear it. Even if I sang it terribly. Actually, especially because I sang it terribly.

Read More